Is the <audio> element part of the "Palpable content" group or not?

Asked

Viewed 35 times

0

I wonder if the element <audio> is part of the group Palpable content, because according to the website WHATWG they mention:

If the element has a Controls attribute: Palpable content.

That is to say if the element <audio> has the attribute controls defined he is part of the group Palpable content not on the contrary, but on W3C they do not mention that the element <audio> is part of the group Palpable content:

Flow content.

Phrasing content.

Embedded content.

If the element has a Controls attribute: Interactive content.

The element <audio> is or is not part of the group Palpable content?

html

  • No offense, but what difference does it make to you? Because you want to know whether or not he’s a Palpable content?

  • @Hugocsl is that I am creating a reference site and in a section of the site I document all the elements, so I need to specify information about the element and one of this information is which group the element is part of.

1 answer

1


First, either one of you has the autonomy to say whatever you want, then whether or not the browser will implement another story... Here you can see something very superficial on the subject Who regulates W3C or WHATWG web standards? Or neither of the two?

But since you want to know... audio with controls, if the browser has controls implemented rss, is a interactive content according to the W3C https://www.w3.org/TR/2016/REC-html51-20161101/dom.html#Kinds-of-content-Interactive-content and the Mozilla says the same thing https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/Guide/HTML/Content_categories.

What does the WHATWG:

inserir a descrição da imagem aqui


If you have controls is Palpable content and is also Interactive content

W3C

inserir a descrição da imagem aqui

  • So he is Palpable content?

  • @felipecardozo if you have controls yes, this is unanimous both for W3C and Whatwg

  • 1

    Thank you very much!

Browser other questions tagged html

You are not signed in. Login or sign up in order to post.